Case Study

CommunityCare Oklahoma

IHP Open Enrollment Campaign

ClientCommunityCare Oklahoma
ScopeStrategy, Creative, Digital Campaign
TimelineNovember 2025 – January 2026
Campaign Creative Digital Marketing

CommunityCare exceeded its IHP enrollment goal for the year

Client-reported outcome. The campaign delivered beyond the business objective it was designed to achieve.

Google conversion rate significantly outperformed the insurance industry benchmark

High-intent targeting and locally rooted messaging drove qualified action throughout the full enrollment window.

Facebook CPMs came in well below the healthcare benchmark

Geographic and audience targeting delivered efficient awareness at scale without overspending on reach.

Drive qualified plan enrollments in a compressed window against well-funded national competitors.

Open enrollment is a defined, high-stakes window. CommunityCare Oklahoma needed to reach adults actively considering Individual and Family health plans across 26 Oklahoma counties and convert that awareness into plan selections before the period closed. A regional health plan competing against national carriers has to reach the right audience with the right message at the right moment.

Local is not just a differentiator. It is the whole story.

National health insurance carriers market coverage while CommunityCare is part of the community it serves. This distinction shapes everything—from how the brand sounds to whom it reaches to why someone chooses it over a lower-priced competitor from out of state. The strategy was built around this truth, leading with local ownership, community connection, and care that feels personal because the people behind it actually live nearby.

Reaching the right Oklahomans with the right message.

High-intent audience targeting across 26 Oklahoma counties reached adults ages 28 to 63 actively searching for health insurance. Three creative platforms carried the message: Quality coverage, close to home. Local, compassionate care. Care that means more. Each addressed a different motivational entry point while staying rooted in the same community truth.

Activating local ownership as a competitive advantage

CommunityCare has been locally owned and operated in Oklahoma for more than 30 years. The campaign leaned into that identity throughout. Email creative positioned CommunityCare as Oklahoma’s trusted provider and your Oklahoma friends and neighbors. The brand was not speaking to a community—it was speaking as one.

Full-funnel digital program built for enrollment.

A three-channel digital program moved qualified prospects from first exposure through to plan selection. Each channel was optimized for a distinct role across the full decision funnel.

Paid Social

Upper funnel — awareness

Facebook and Instagram reach campaign across the full enrollment geography. CPMs well below the healthcare benchmark.

Performance Max

Mid funnel — consideration

Google automated inventory across YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail, and Maps. Drove the majority of clicks and reach with strong efficiency.

Paid Search

Lower funnel — conversion

Non-branded keyword targeting capturing high-intent queries at the moment of active decision-making throughout the enrollment period.

CommunityCare Senior Health Plan 2022

Services
Delivered

Campaign Creative Digital Marketing Healthcare